Friday, October 12, 2012

Chapter 4 reading reflections

When creating a project it is important for it to be purposeful and have meaning. Teachers need to make sure they do not fall into any of the common pitfalls. Pitfall number one is: “long on activity, short on learning outcomes.” A project should be meaningful and students should learn things from the project that they would not learn by reading a textbook. The outcome of the project should be aligned with the amount of time spent doing it. The project should be worth the student’s time, and the teachers. The next pitfall is “technology layered over traditional practice.” There is a different between using technology in the classroom, and a project with technology assisting in the learning. “Trivial thematic units” is the next pitfall. Thematic teaching is not always project-based learning. The work should be collaborative and interdisciplinary. The last pitfall this chapter mentions is “Over scripted with many, many steps.” If the project has too many steps it takes the critical decision making and thinking out of the project. There are many aspects of a good project. They are flexible and allow students to take control of their learning and to construct meaning to the project. They are collaborative and students learn from each other. Students get a hands-on experience that uses 21st century skills. It centers on a question and allows students to discover their own answers. Ideas for great projects come from a variety of places. It could be a project the teacher or teacher’s designs for their students. It could be a project plan that is developed by another teacher. Inspiration can be found in contemporary issues, student’s questions or their interests. It could be because of classroom irritants or because of new stories. There are four main steps of designing a project. Step one of designing a project is revisit the framework. A final list of the learning objectives should be made and the specific 21-century skill that should be addressed needs to be determined. Step two is to establish evidence of understanding. Think about what tools you will use to evaluate. Step three is to plan the “vehicle” (the theme/challenge.) What real- world connections can be made? Step four is to plan entrĂ©e into the project experiences. How will you get your students excited at the beginning of the project? This chapter addresses many things that will help us develop and effective project on preserving food. It will help us avoid falling into the common pitfalls. It also provides a basic outline for developing a project.

4 comments:

  1. The first pitfall and your response to it made me nod my head yes! I agree that students need a project that is not too long without having an amazing outcome! I remember having these horribly long projects in school and not being proud of the outcome in the end, which was extremely frustrating as a student. Some projects weren't worth my time and I'm assuming not worth the teacher's time either. I also agree that students should be allowed to make some decisions with their projects and if they are too structured by the teacher then they won't be able to do that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree that many of my teachers in elementary-highschool made us do projects that took weeks on end, such as our "future career goal" where we had to research our future careers but the outcome was not satisfying because we were never shown how to accurately search our careers. Thus, I was always frustrated with my future! Also, when projects are terribly long but still hold educational value, it allows you to teach more projects and the students can learn a variety of material.

      Delete
    2. I was just going to comment on this concept too! I strongly agree in the statement included above, "The project should be worth the student’s time, and the teachers." I can remember a handful of projects that were worth my time and that I did benefit from the process of the project. But there were also times that I remember I was constantly questioning the importance of a project because I saw no benefit for me, or anyone else for that matter, even the teacher. That idea will definitely be something I think about before I give my students a project :)

      Delete
  2. I really do think that it is important to be aware of the pitfalls, that we as teachers could possibly fall into. I completely agree “long on activity, short on learning outcomes.” When teaching you want to do something that will stick with them, and something that is meaningful. You can learn so much from doing hands on projects that you may not learn from a textbook, because it is not being applied. I know for me I learn by doing, and the projects provide that that textbooks can't. You never want to have too many steps in one project, it is important to keep on track and stick to the important parts.

    ReplyDelete